Bestseller Collection

Filter

    Our Top Six Favorites
    Discover the Fustini’s flavors our customers love most. This collection features our best-selling 18 Year balsamic and Sicilian Lemon balsamic, paired with four vibrant olive oils: Garlic, Tuscan Herb, Basil Crush, and Meyer Lemon. Each one brings bold, versatile flavor to your kitchen—perfect for drizzling, dipping, dressing, or marinating. These six are popular for a reason.

    6 products
    18 Year Traditional Balsamic Vinegar (Dark)
    From $9.95
    Garlic Olive Oil
    From $9.95
    Tuscan Herb Olive Oil
    From $9.95
    Basil Crush Olive Oil
    From $9.95
    Meyer Lemon Olive Oil
    From $9.95
    Sicilian Lemon Balsamic (White)
    From $9.95
    Petoskey
    Ann Arbor
    Traverse City
    Holland

    Visit our Tasting Rooms

    Discover the difference of Fustini’s oils and vinegars at our Michigan stores in Holland, Ann Arbor, Traverse City, and Petoskey. Taste, learn, and get inspired with flavorful, healthy ingredients.

    Try our oils and vinegars, ask questions, and find ideas for cooking with help from our friendly, knowledgeable staff.

    Our Recipes

    Reset Salad
    Reset Salad
    Fustini's French 75
    Fustini's French 75
    Brighten your celebrations with a Fustini’s twist on a classic French 75. Our Sicilian Lemon Balsamic replaces simple syrup for a naturally vibrant sweetness, perfectly balancing gin, fresh lemon, and sparkling wine....
    'Good on Everything' Vinaigrette
    'Good on Everything' Vinaigrette
    Raspberry Hot Cocoa
    Raspberry Hot Cocoa
    This simple twist to instant hot cocoa is sure to be a hit with the whole family! 
    Elegant Olive Tapenade
    Elegant Olive Tapenade
    Green Goddess Dressing
    Green Goddess Dressing
    Sicilian Lemon Drop Martini
    Sicilian Lemon Drop Martini
    Olive Oil Pumpkin Cake With Salted Maple Cream
    Olive Oil Pumpkin Cake With Salted Maple Cream
    Butternut Squash Soup
    Butternut Squash Soup
    Maple Cider Vinaigrette
    Maple Cider Vinaigrette
    Herb Pantry Balsamic Dressing
    Herb Pantry Balsamic Dressing
    Simple, elegant, versatile. You won't find a better balsamic vinaigrette! This recipe card is included with the purchase of our Herb Pantry Pairing gift box.
    Garlic Focaccia
    Garlic Focaccia
    Make warm, fragrant Garlic Focaccia at home with our new Bread Dipping Gift Box, which includes the focaccia mix, garlic olive oil, balsamic, a dipping dish, and a Tuscan spice blend to...